Scope: Switzerland. Check procedures and conditions specific to the canton and project.
From the brief to a documented decision
- 01
Describe
One shared scope for all contractors.
- 02
Compare
Separate services, exclusions and assumptions.
- 03
Clarify
Get written answers on important differences.
- 04
Decide
Keep the chosen version and reasons for selection.
In this guide
- Use one shared brief
- Ask for a breakdown
- Check the terms
- Example: a cheaper quote with exclusions
- 1. Define the result, not just the equipment
- 2. Document the existing building
- 3. Decide who coordinates the work
- 4. Use one shared brief
- 5. Read exclusions before totals
- 6. A comparison example without invented market prices
- 7. Turn uncertainty into questions
- 8. Build the complete budget
- 9. Agree changes before execution
- 10. Prepare the handover file
- 11. Build a comparison matrix you can actually use
- Your practical next step
Renovation quote comparison sheet
Fill in the sheet for two quotes covering the same work. Note what still needs to be confirmed in writing.
Your notes stay on this page and are cleared when you leave.
Find a trades business in French-speaking Switzerland ↗Use one shared brief
Describe areas, existing condition, desired outcome, access and timing. Give each contractor the same photographs and information.
Ask for a breakdown
Separate materials, installation, adaptations, removal, disposal, travel and taxes. Identify exclusions and provisional amounts.
Check the terms
Compare schedules, payments, offered warranties and how extra work is handled. Have scope changes confirmed in writing before work begins.
Example: a cheaper quote with exclusions
Equipment replacement quotes may omit removal, connections or finishing work. Request those items before judging the price. Compare revised quotes for the same scope and retain written agreements.
1. Define the result, not just the equipment
Describe the condition you want after the work. For a bathroom, that includes finishes, ventilation and access to installations. For heating, explain the rooms affected and current problems. Separate essentials from optional improvements. A clear result helps contractors price the same requirement instead of making different assumptions about what a successful renovation includes.
2. Document the existing building
Collect plans, dated photographs and records of previous work. Identify areas that have not been inspected. A quote based on photographs may contain significant assumptions. Give contractors equivalent opportunities to inspect. Ask how work discovered later will be measured and approved. Documentation cannot eliminate surprises, but it can make uncertainty visible before a decision.
3. Decide who coordinates the work
One contractor may be enough for a limited intervention. With several trades, coordination of visits, interfaces and handover becomes a separate responsibility. Ask who owns it. For energy renovation, the CECB Plus combines the building energy certificate with an advisory report and renovation options. It is not a construction quote or a guarantee of funding. Clarify advisory needs before requesting many proposals.
4. Use one shared brief
Record the current state, desired outcome, known quantities, access, protection, working hours and preferred dates. Send the same version to every contractor. Share new information from inspections with all bidders. Request a base proposal and separate options. Without a common brief, totals may describe different quantities, finishes and responsibilities rather than genuine price differences.
5. Read exclusions before totals
Look for excluded preparation, connections, decorating, removal, cleaning and special access. Ask which figures are fixed, estimated or measured after work. Establish responsibility for missing items. A lower proposal may simply contain less. Request a revised quotation from the contractor rather than inserting your own estimate for missing work and treating the result as confirmed.
6. A comparison example without invented market prices
Quote A includes equipment and fitting. Quote B also includes removal, disposal and making good. Request those items from A, then check that connections and protection are equivalent. Only after clarification are the scopes comparable. Alternative brands or technologies belong in separate options. The decision should relate to a written scope understood by both parties.
7. Turn uncertainty into questions
Maintain three columns: open point, responsible person and written answer required. Restricted access, hidden substrates and old installations may need inspection. Ask which investigations could reduce uncertainty and whether they cost extra. Technical hazards or suspect materials require suitable specialist advice. Silence in a quotation does not confirm a sound building. Keep answers with the relevant quotation version.
8. Build the complete budget
Separate priced work, options, professional fees, investigations and temporary arrangements. Identify included taxes and how variations are handled. Decide a contingency based on uncertainty rather than applying a universal percentage. Before subtracting assistance, confirm eligibility, conditions and timing with the responsible authority. Rules vary by location and project. An unconfirmed contribution should not be treated as secured funding.
9. Agree changes before execution
Request a programme showing trade dependencies and interruptions to services. Decide who informs occupants and answers questions. For each change, obtain its description, price impact and timing impact before written approval. Verbal exchanges alone can make tracking difficult. Keep a variation log and hold progress discussions suited to the size of the work.
10. Prepare the handover file
Review agreed work with the contractor and record outstanding points. Request operating instructions, equipment details, commissioning records and maintenance contacts. Have operation explained where relevant. Retain invoices and correspondence with the building records. An organised handover documents the outcome; it does not replace specialist assessment when a technical problem remains unresolved.
11. Build a comparison matrix you can actually use
Our editorial method is to put quotations in columns and services in rows. Start from the shared brief issued to all contractors. For each item, record the stated quantity, product or finish, included work and information still missing. Do not enter zero for an omitted service. Mark it as not priced and request clarification. Otherwise, an incomplete total can look like an established saving. Give coordination, protection, cleaning and handover documents their own checking rows. If these services are covered by a package price, ask where they are included rather than counting them twice. Keep optional upgrades outside the base comparison so that an attractive alternative does not silently change the assumptions used to compare the other offers. For timing, distinguish stated availability, estimated duration and dependencies on other trades. For payments, copy the proposed stages and ask what event triggers each instalment. Add a status column: comparable, clarification requested or revised version awaited. Have a telephone answer confirmed in writing before marking an issue resolved. Retain earlier versions, but identify the current one clearly. When an offer changes, record the date and affected items. A new total is not enough if materials, quantities or responsibilities have changed at the same time. The matrix does not select a contractor for you or turn proposed terms into legal warranties. It makes differences visible, supports focused questions and records the reasons for your decision. Have important technical questions reviewed by a qualified person before considering the comparison complete.
Your practical next step
Photograph and describe the need, gather records and prepare the shared brief. Arrange inspections with appropriate contractors. When proposals arrive, identify differences and exclusions before immediately requesting a discount. Ask for consolidated clarifications and compare the answers. You can then select on scope, method, timing and terms, rather than the headline total alone.
Editorial checklist prepared with AI assistance. General guidance; technical, legal and financial points need individual verification.
FAQ
Is the cheapest quote automatically the best?
No. Compare services, exclusions and assumptions first. Ask the contractor to price additions; your own estimates are not confirmed quotation amounts.
Does a CECB Plus replace contractors’ quotations?
No. Its advisory report helps assess energy renovation options. The services and prices for the work must then be clarified with the proposed contractors.
Can I deduct advertised grants from my budget?
Separate possible assistance from confirmed amounts. Check the relevant canton’s conditions and deadlines. General information is not a decision on your own application.
Your question, our next article?
Ask about this topic. Selected questions may become articles or FAQ updates without publishing your email. Avoid confidential information.
